June 23, 2024

George Clooney, Ben Affleck, Scarlett Johansson and a group of other A-listers gave a proposal to SAG-AFTRA leadership on Tuesday, which they hoped would help end the 98-day actors strike.

But the proposal was rejected on Wednesday by the union’s negotiating committee, which is sticking to the demands it has spelled out over many weeks of negotiations.

To understand why, it might help to delve more deeply into the proposal.

There are two main elements: a dues increase on high-earning actors and a change in residuals to ensure that low-earning actors get paid first.

Dues Increase

Under current rules, SAG-AFTRA members pay $231.96 in base dues each year, plus 1.575% of covered earnings up to $1 million. The A-listers’ proposal would eliminate that cap, subjecting all covered actor earnings to the 1.575% assessment.

Clooney has estimated that would generate $50 million a year. (That sounds high, as it would imply that actors earn about $3.2 billion a year above the cap, which is the equivalent of about 160 actors averaging $21 million a year, which is a reach.)

More to the point, the major problem with this is that the SAG-AFTRA strike is not about dues. SAG-AFTRA is on strike to increase actors’ income, not to increase the funding of the union. The two things are not interchangeable. An increase in union dues could not offset payments owed by studios to actors or to the actors’ pension and health funds.

Dues are also irrelevant to the collective bargaining process, as they are not subject to negotiation between the union and the Alliance of Motion Picture and Television Producers. They are set by the SAG-AFTRA National Board, which would have to undertake a separate process, which would involve selling high-earning actors on the idea of a paying more to the union.

And while SAG-AFTRA would likely find a use for any additional money, the union is not suffering from a decline in dues. The union reported receiving $127 million last fiscal year, a significant increase from the year prior as production rebounded to pre-pandemic levels.

Fran Drescher, the president of SAG-AFTRA, explained that dues cannot be used to fund the pension and health plans in an Instagram video released Thursday night.

“That’s kind of apples and oranges,” she explained. And increase in dues, she said, “does not impact the contract that we’re striking over whatsoever.”

‘Bottom-Up’ Residual Structure

The group also proposes a residual structure in which the lowest-earning actors would be paid first, and the highest earners would get residuals last.

This appears to confuse residuals with profit participation. A-list actors can negotiate a percentage of profits, which are paid out on the backend in a “waterfall” system. As more profits come in, the money starts to flow further down, so it makes a big difference where an actor is positioned in the waterfall.

That isn’t how residuals work. Residuals are paid out at the same time to everybody who is owed them. Every time a project is sold to a new medium, or re-aired on TV, the union contracts spell out exactly who is owed what. Residuals have nothing to do with profits. There is no “waterfall,” and it doesn’t matter where an actor is positioned.

Drescher also addressed the residual proposal in her Instagram video.

“That was vetted by our very experienced union contract staff, negotiators and lawyers, and they said that it unfortunately doesn’t hold water,” she said. “Frankly this is a very nuanced house of cards.”


In other words, neither of these proposals addresses the problems that have kept actors on strike for 98 days. Those issues are: a union proposal to pay actors a share of streaming revenue, an increase in minimums to keep pace with inflation, and regulations on artificial intelligence.

The proposals appear to be motivated by a sincere desire to bring an end to the strike, coupled with a sense of noblesse oblige, suggesting that high-earning actors should sacrifice to reach that resolution.

From the standpoint of the SAG-AFTRA Negotiating Committee, however, the proposal appears to weaken the sense of unity and commitment to the committee’s proposals — which is key to reaching the best possible deal. It also suggests that high-earning actors should somehow step in to pay for things that the studios have refused to pay for — thereby lessening the pressure on the studios to pony up.

Asked what A-list actors could do to help reach a resolution, one person close to the talks suggested that they join a picket line.


pull the pin mod apk v0 138 1 unlimited coins playmods
evony apk mod unlimited gems 2022 ios and android twitter
pdf free dice dreams rolls generator update 2023 vi7q
project makeover game hacks tiktok search
download beach buggy racing mod apk 2021 premium
Free TikTok Coins: Where to Find Them
Où trouver des pièces gratuites sur TikTok : Votre guide
How to Legally and Quickly Get Free Spins in Coin Master
Unlocking Free Avacoins in Avakin Life: A Comprehensive Guide
Free Credits in Bingo Blitz: Insider Secrets
Earn Free Spins in Coin Master Like a Pro
genshin impact codes guide get free primogems and mora
How to Get ZEPETO Zems Legally and Quickly
match masters free coins archives crazyashwin
Free TikTok Coins: The Holy Grail of Success
Free Gems in Brawl Stars: The Future of Brawl Gaming
new cheats dragon city free gems mod generator freemind
free family island hack cheats unlimited rubies and energy
hay day hack generator s profile hackaday io
litmatch mod apk 2022 free vip mod unlimited diamond
myths of moonrise by starfortune apps games appgrooves
pdf portable generator buffalo tools
mcqlm evony the kings return hack new 2022 updated
dice dreams v1 53 2 10316 mod apk unlimited rolls coins spin
project makeover unlimited coins cheat ios android 100 working
beach buggy racing mod apk 2023 01 11 free purchase
How to Earn TikTok Coins: Step-by-Step Tutorial
Sicherheit geht Vor: Schützen Sie Ihr Konto beim Verdienen von Münzen
Mastering the Art of Earning Free Spins in Coin Master
Avakin Life Avacoins Hack: Expert Recommendations

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *